top of page
5f4b874b-46b6-43f7-9efe-3543f6c47f67.jpg

Rebel's Rebuttal

When I smell garbage being spewed and facts being distorted I fire back!

Rebuttal to Senator Schumer's Claims

Legal doesn't mean appropriate policy. These families often receive more in benefits than working Americans earn in wages. Schumer's word games can't hide the massive taxpayer burden his policies create.

Rebel Lawson

Senator Schumer is technically correct but deliberately misleading. While undocumented adults cannot directly receive ACA, Medicare, or Medicaid benefits, his statement conveniently ignores how these households actually access substantial government benefits.


The reality Schumer won't acknowledge: Undocumented immigrants with US citizen children receive massive taxpayer subsidies through legal "child-only" benefit programs. Here are the facts:


What Mixed-Status Families Actually Receive

For a household with 2 undocumented parents and 6 US citizen children:


SNAP benefits: Up to $1,421/month for the 6 eligible children


TANF cash assistance: $450-$1,700/month depending on state (California provides up to $1,600/month in direct cash)


Free healthcare: Comprehensive Medicaid/CHIP coverage worth $800+/month in premium value


Total monthly benefits: $2,500-$3,000+ on top of wages


The Numbers Don't Lie

59% of undocumented immigrant households use at least one major welfare program


Child-only TANF cases represent 50% of all TANF recipients


42% of these child-only cases involve undocumented parents


Working American taxpayers fund approximately $30,000-36,000 annually per mixed-status household receiving maximum benefits


The Legal Loophole Schumer Exploits

Yes, it's legal. US citizen children are entitled to benefits regardless of their parents' immigration status. But legal doesn't mean appropriate policy. These families often receive more in government benefits than many working American families earn in wages.


The Real Question

Senator Schumer can play word games about direct versus indirect benefit access, but the economic reality remains: American taxpayers are subsidizing undocumented immigrant households to the tune of $2,500-3,000+ monthly through various programs.


While I support ensuring US citizen children are cared for, we must acknowledge that current policy creates perverse incentives that encourage illegal immigration by providing substantial economic support. The system essentially guarantees a middle-class income through benefits alone.


Schumer's technically accurate but misleading statements obscure a massive taxpayer burden that deserves honest discussion, not political spin.

bottom of page